Sunday in the South means church, and up until recently, the “high church” ruled the area. For those unfamiliar with the term “high church”, it simply is the word for attention put on ritual. Southern Sundays consist of rising early, putting on your Sunday best, and heading to church to pray, tithe and hear the Word.
Most Sunday afternoons are then spent congregating with family around a home-cooked meal. While “high church” is a beautiful tradition, it is not the preferred method of worship for all, especially with millennials. With the changing of the tide and the needs of the “flock”, it is up to church leaders to ensure they are providing worship experiences that attract everyone.
First Presbyterian Church, located at 102 Ann Street, right in downtown Fayetteville, is reimagining the church, offering two uniquely diverse ways to connect with the Church and God. Associate Pastor, Jeff Shaver, is leading the charge with Theology of Tap and Cross Creek Fellowship. Theology on Tap is a new idea, that incorporates old psychology.
As Pastor Jeff said, “I don’t care if you doubt. None of us wake up in the morning and is like ‘hey I have this all figured out.’ We’re all just trying to figure out what's real and what's not…and I’m one of them. So having a safe place like Theology on Tap, where it’s that sanctuary you can bring your doubts, you can bring your questions, you can bring whatever, I don’t care."
"This is not about trying to argue with you. It’s just good conversation over a drink or two," he said.
Cross Creek Fellowship is an extension of Theology of Tap.
“Our first sermon series is going to be called ‘The Church of Misfit Toys.’ I love Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer and there’s an island of misfit toys, well I think there are a lot of people, and I’m one of them, that in traditional churches don’t feel like… I feel like I’m a misfit toy. So I’ve always felt you could create a whole other church from people who feel like that….
"You’re not here for it, it’s here for YOU. Meaning that if you don’t show up on a Sunday, you’re not going to get bombarded with ‘where are you,’.... I do these things and sometimes I’ll get 15 people and sometimes I’ll get two. And I don’t care. The numbers aren’t important to me. It’s about creating these little places where people can go and just feel like, ‘oh this is here when I need it.’ … Being able to be in somebody’s life, even as a spiritual person, that's a privilege. That’s a privilege, that’s not a right,” Pastor Jeff said.
First Prez, as it’s affectionately known, has a full calendar for every member of the family. Kingdom Kids is a Christian Education and music program for kids Pre-K to high school.
They meet every Sunday from 4:30 p.m. to 6:30 p.m. Vacation Bible School will begin soon with the theme, Scuba Diving into Friendship with God. VBS will run from June 17 to 20, from 9 a.m. to noon. Registration is now open.
First Prez is much more than its historical building; it is a lively community, of loving and active Christians, seeking to better the community not just through words, but action.

(Photo: Paster Jeff Shaver of First Presbyterian Church.  Photo by Amber Little)